This is kind of a long one, and I can’t guarantee any of it will make sense, so bear with me…
It’s been one of those months where it seems that everywhere I turn, I find a story that makes me wonder if a peaceful coexistence between Christian conservative and secular Americans might be impossible to attain. I hate, hate, hate feeling this way, so thoroughly disappointed and disillusioned with humanity. I reached a breaking point last night. And an incident today broke me just a little bit more.
As I lay in bed, trying pointlessly to fall asleep at a reasonable hour, I fired up my iPod to an old This American Life podcast I hadn’t heard yet. The episode was called, “Nobody’s Family Is Going to Change,” and the first act was a pretty heartbreaking story about a woman whose brother suddenly became a born-again Christian and moved off to some remote commune-type place in Alaska with other born-again Christians. As you can imagine, this placed no small amount of strain on the relationship between this woman (a lesbian and secular Jew) and her born-again brother. Their relationship was basically broken after one disastrous visit, in which her brother flew out to see her in Paris, where she was living at the time with another woman. Openly condemning her “lifestyle,” he refused to stay in the same apartment with them. She and her girlfriend had to stay somewhere else and leave the apartment to her brother.
They pretty much quit speaking after that.
Years later, this woman went out to Alaska to try and mend her relationship with her brother. While they were able to recapture some of the closeness they shared as children, there were a few conversations that made me cringe. Every time this woman asked her brother a question, what he believed about something or other, he consulted the Bible. He seemed completely steadfast in his beliefs, unwilling (or unable) to consider any alternatives. No matter how much they tried to understand each other, there always seemed to be an impenetrable glass wall between them.
This story really drove home for me how we secular folks and the hardcore Christians really are speaking two different languages. Sooner or later, we’re going to hit that wall.
I lay there in the dark, vocally venting my frustration to an empty room. (Empty except for my dogs, that is, who were more than a little freaked out by my outburst.)
I feel like I’ve tried really, really hard to understand where conservative Christians are coming from. Probably not as hard as I could’ve tried, but I feel like I’ve given a fair effort. I’ve had lengthy conversations with several different people. I’ve read. I’ve visited different churches. And I think I get what it’s all about – to a certain superficial extent, anyway.
There’s this book, and in order to be “good,” you have to believe everything (or nearly everything) within it to be true. Most issues are clearly reducible to black and white terms. It either meshes with what’s in the book, or it doesn’t.
I’m sure my Secular Outsider perspective would seem greatly oversimplified to a Christian Conservative Insider, but I think it’s more or less the gist of it. And I definitely see the appeal. I do. I understand it. It takes a lot of the murkiness out of life. There’s a fairly clear code of conduct, and an automatic source of comfort when you need it. There is only one Right Way, and those who do not follow your same path are deemed (either silently or loudly) as Sinners.
But at the same time, the concept of belief in an intelligent being who watches us to see how accurately we’re following his rules is completely, 100% foreign to me. I don’t know if I’ll ever be able to really, truly understand how someone could believe something that, to me, seems so incredibly weird and improbable. For years, I’ve thought long and hard about this, and the more I think about it, the weirder and more improbable it seems.
Yeah – you hear that sound? That’s the sound of my face smacking into the glass wall.
Such a belief, or lack thereof, seems like such a fundamental (so to speak) aspect of who one really is. Some believe in God, some don’t. Some people believe in ghosts and ESP, and some don’t. It’s possible, I’m sure, to reach a certain level of mutual understanding, but eventually aren’t you just going to hit that barrier?
Is it even necessary that we understand each other? Maybe it’s not. Maybe I’m spending far too much time and energy worrying about something that doesn’t even matter. I’d like to think that we live in a country, a world, where people genuinely want to understand and relate to their neighbor, but maybe that’s just a naïve pipe dream. Maybe all we can really do is just try to stay out of each other’s way whenever we can, and then hope for the best when we can’t.
That just doesn’t seem like the answer, though. Simply picking a side and giving that glass wall a good Windexing while glaring through it at the people on the other side isn’t ever going to make things better. That’s precisely how stereotypes and prejudices develop and fester.
Obviously, people are incredibly complex, and even though I just got done dishing out my lameass version of Conservative Christianity in a Nutshell, it clearly isn’t going to apply to all conservative Christians all of the time. And this is to say nothing of all the Christians who don’t consider themselves theologically conservative, which is why I’m not including them here (sorry, guys). It’s pretty much impossible, tempting though it sometimes may be, to lump everyone in together with one dismissive wave of the hand – “ehh, they’re all crazy.”
While it’s true that you can never really know what it’s like inside someone else’s head, I think it’s also true that sometimes you can see things in other people that they themselves don’t see. When you’re busy being you, it’s easy to lose perspective. We take things for granted, and maybe don’t question certain ideas and attitudes that we might do well to question. Maybe that’s where we can help each other out.
Obviously, there are some people who could care less about any of this. They’re right, everyone else is wrong, and they have no interest in considering anyone else’s point of view. They’re only interested in proving to them why they’re wrong. I’ll come right out and say that I have little interest in those kinds of people, the ones who like the glass wall. So does that make me a hypocrite if I make no real effort to understand them or empathize with their point of view? I don’t know. Maybe I should be the bigger person and try even harder. Or maybe that’s just wasting time and energy that could be better spent helping shelter dogs find homes, watching a great film, or talking to nicer people.