I am the Proletariat
So, I’ve been thinking lately about elite theory – the idea that society is basically structured like a pyramid, with military leaders, political party leaders and business leaders at the pinnacle. Just beneath them, you’ll find the “professional class” (federal politicians, academicians, top-level bureaucrats and business people). Filling out the bottom of the pyramid is the rest of us.
Okay, so elite theory is sometimes criticized as being little more than a conspiracy theory or justification for Communism, but I don’t know if you could persuade me that there isn’t some truth to it.
I thought about this while sitting in class the other night. Most of my classes seem to be split between Master’s students and Ph.D. students, with varying concentrations of one or the other. It could be nothing more than my own insecurity, but sometimes I feel like the Master’s students are kind of second-class citizens. Much discussion seems to focus on the Ph.D. people – what they’re doing, what they’ve done, or what research they plan to do in the future. They have a certain connection with the professor that the rest of lack. Together, they inhabit their shared world of academia, whereas the rest of us toil away at various bureaucratic-type jobs. I also wonder how many of them think that academia is the superior world in which to live.
I was still thinking about all of this when I watched Bill Clinton speak yesterday. I thought about the difference in the way this one event was likely viewed by him and viewed by me. For him, this was one stop of several he had planned for that day. He says the same things over and over, in different states, to different people. Who knows how many speeches like this he’s given throughout his career, with this single event in Norman blending seamlessly into all the thousands of other events.
Then you have me, as well as the thousands of other people lined up in front of the OU Fieldhouse that morning, to whom this event was kind of a big deal. I’d planned my day around it, and I was embarrassingly excited about seeing a Real-Life Former President. This was something most of us will remember for the rest of our lives. Oh, some of us might be all cool and blasé about it, but it’s still a much bigger deal for us than it is for Clinton.
I guess what I’m getting at is this – it’s a really weird feeling to be very much into yourself, your life, your problems, and then realize that you are but one featureless face bobbing up and down in a sea of nondescript humanity. Sometimes you might feel like you’re special. You’re smarter than other people, or more creative. You’re better than everyone else. But you’re not. There are people out there looking down upon you with the same condescension you might feel towards those you view to be less enlightened than you. No matter how clever you might think you are, there are people out there who think you’re a total philistine.
I am the proletariat. I am one more worker bee to be controlled and exploited by whoever is in charge. I suppose it’s possible to find some significance or dignity in my utterly unremarkable existence, but ultimately, I am nothing. I am replaceable. I am indistinguishable.
I’m getting a cold shower of humility right about now.




